Comments on Arthur B's If Ever a Wiz There...

Arthur is very impressed by Geoff Ryman's Was.
Comments
Hurrah! A review from Arthur! I thought you'd been pretty quiet recently, but now I see you were bogged down in despair. Coincidentally, have you read Wicked?
at 15:54 on 2007-06-19 by Kyra Smith
Not yet; it's not really engaged my interest.
at 17:10 on 2007-06-19 by Arthur B
That's fair. It's almost not entirely worth it. It's interesting for a bit but then it's too heavily constrained by the story it's re-telling, if that makes sense. Things happen because they occur in the original book, not because it seems sensible/relevant that they should. The musical looks fun though!
at 11:18 on 2007-06-21 by Kyra Smith
In order to post comments, you need to log in to Ferretbrain. Don't have an account? See the About Us page for more details.

Back to "If Ever a Wiz There..."